ChatGPT, Bing, Bard, Or Claude: Generative AI Chatbot Comparison

ChatGPT, Bing, Bard, Or Claude: Generative AI Chatbot Comparison

With the rapid onset of generative AI chatbots, you may wonder which is best for your needs.

With the recent release of Google Bard, we decided to test it against ChatGPT, Bing, and Claude to see responses for prompts on search engine optimization, website coding, content generation, productivity tools, news, and social media.

Specifically, we used the following versions of each AI chatbot for the upcoming examples.

  • ChatGPT from OpenAI using GPT-4 with a plus subscription at $20 monthly.
  • Bing AI, powered by GPT-4, in the Microsoft Edge Dev desktop browser.
  • The first/experimental release of Google Bard in the Google Chrome desktop browser.
  • Claude+, the ethical rival of ChatGPT, on Poe in a desktop browser with a premium subscription at $20 monthly.

Now, let’s look at some prompts marketers might use and the responses they could receive from each of these chatbots to see which one is best.

Prompt #1: “What Is SEO?”

The first prompt is a simple question – what is SEO? You might receive the following responses from ChatGPT, Bing (More Balanced), Bard, and Claude+.

ChatGPT purely defined SEO – search engine optimization – followed by its purpose and key aspects of the process. No sources were provided, as it uses training data from articles, blog posts, books, and websites from September 2021 or earlier.

ChatGPT response to prompt: what is seoScreenshot from ChatGPT, March 2023

Bing AI chat provided a shorter answer with several sources and three additional prompt suggestions to learn more about SEO.

Bing AI response to prompt: what is seoScreenshot from Bing, March 2023

Google Bard gave us three answers to choose from using the drafts dropdown. The first answer did not provide sources. The second (shown below) and third answers were based on different sources.

Google Bard response to prompt: what is seoScreenshot from Bard, March 2023

Claude+ offered a detailed answer with what appeared to be internal links.

Claude+ response to prompt: what is seoScreenshot from Poe, March 2023

When you click on one of the links, it prompts Claude to give you another answer.

Claude+ response to prompt: what is seoScreenshot from Poe, March 2023

Prompt #2: “How Can I Get High-Quality Backlinks For My Website?”

Next, we asked how to get high-quality backlinks for a website.

ChatGPT listed link-building techniques that were heavily promoted in 2021.

ChatGPT response to prompt: how to get high quality backlinksScreenshot from ChatGPT, March 2023

Bing AI offered five suggestions with sources, such as using tools like Ahrefs and Semrush to research competitors’ backlinks.

Bing AI response to prompt: how to get high quality backlinksScreenshot from Bing, March 2023

Google Bard gave three distinct answers to the question but no sources. Included in Bard’s suggestions were blog commenting, forum posts, and directory submissions, as shown in this third draft.

google bard on high quality linksScreenshot from Bard, March 2023

Claude+ offered many suggestions, including private blog networks and Yahoo Answers, which no longer exist.

poe claude high quality backlinksScreenshot from Poe, March 2023
poe claude high quality backlinksScreenshot from Poe, March 2023

Prompt #3: “Can You Give Me The HTML To Create A One-Page Portfolio Website?”

Can generative AI chatbots code a simple website?

ChatGPT provided HTML and CSS that could be copied and pasted.

chatgpt website code html cssScreenshot from ChatGPT, March 2023

Using W3Schools TryIt Editor, we proved the code does create a functional webpage.

chatgpt website code test Screenshot from W3Schools, March
Read More